Best Places to Sell Your Broken Apple Watch (Damaged or Faulty) (Apr 2025)
Learn about our editorial process
Learn about our editorial process
Learn about our editorial process
- You can sell a faulty or damaged Apple Watch in-store or online. Selling it in-store, however, gives you 30% to 50% less than the value you’ll get from selling at online buyback stores.
- Do you want to compare quotes from different trade-in sites? We have already done the work for you. Check the price comparison of leading US buyers of Apple Watch units with BankMyCell!
- Did you know that not all buyback prices are equal? So make sure you check our tools first for quick comparison and get the best deal. Compare Quotes Now
Who Buys Broken Apple Watches (Compare Quotes)
BankMyCell compares over 100,000+ quotes and customer reviews from 20+ trusted buyback stores every 15 minutes via our data feeds, making us America’s #1 time-saving trade-in supermarket.
| Buyback Company | Damaged Price Difference vs. Best Price | Cracked Price Difference vs. Best Price | Trustpilot Rating | Payout Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BankMyCell Compare 20+ quotes | BEST OFFER | BEST OFFER | 4.4 out of 5 | Cash |
| Decluttr | -21.85% | -53.11% | 4.6 out of 5 | Cash |
| Buyback World | -74.07% | -17.10% | 4.1 out of 5 | Cash |
| SmartphonesPlus | No Offers* | -88.89% | 4.0 out of 5 | Cash |
| Retail Store Trade-in | Price Difference | Price Difference | Trustpilot Rating | Payout Type |
| BankMyCell Compare 20+ quotes | BEST OFFER | BEST OFFER | 4.4 out of 5 | Cash |
| GameStop | -14.07% | -48.44% | 2.4 out of 5 | Store Credit |
| Target | -36.67% | -66.67% | 1.9 out of 5 | Store Credit |
| Walmart | -81.48% | -88.89% | 1.4 out of 5 | Store Credit |
| Best Buy | No Offers* | -49.52% | 1.3 out of 5 | Gift Card |
| EcoATM | No Offers* | No Offers* | 3.3 out of 5 | Cash |
| Apple | No Offers* | -45.23% | 1.6 out of 5 | Store Credit |
| Carrier Trade-in | Price Difference | Price Difference | Trustpilot Rating | Payout Type |
| BankMyCell Compare 20+ quotes | BEST OFFER | BEST OFFER | 4.4 out of 5 | Cash |
| Verizon | 74.67 | -57.78% | 1.4 out of 5 | Store Credit |
| AT&T | -80.00% | -66.67% | 1.2 out of 5 | Store Credit |
| Sprint | No Offers* | -71.11% | 1.2 out of 5 | Store Credit |
| T-Mobile | No Offers* | -71.11% | 1.6 out of 5 | Store Credit |
*Percentages were calculated using each store’s average price of the five most popular broken Apple Watches.
Turn Your Broken Apple Watch into Cash - Fast
Buyback stores offer higher pay outs than trading in in-store. You can still sell your device with buyback stores even if your device has a cracked screen.
Get 100% of the Device Market Value with Buyback Stores
Sell your Apple Watch through a trusted buyback company and get the top value for your broken device. Follow these steps:
- Start by searching for your Apple Watch model here
- Select “Cracked or Faulty” in the filters to get an instant quotes.
- Compare quote, ship for free, get paid.
What’s my Apple Watch worth: Series 7 | Series 6 | Series 5 | Nike Series
Lose up to 65% of the Device Market Value Selling In-Store
You can sell your device back to the carrier or to big box stores however they will offer you a far lower quote, and often badly damaged Apple Watches are excluded from their offers. In many cases these stores will only offer store credit rather than cash payouts.
Big Box Stores:
- Average Loss: 44% Less than online buyback stores
- Process: Sell your broken Apple Watch to a retail store and get store credit (low payouts).
Carrier Stores:
- Average Loss: 77% Less than online buyback stores
- Process: Visit a carrier store and receive credit you can use for deals or upgrades. (medium payouts).
What Types of Broken Apple Watch can I Sell
When you sell your Apple Watch make sure to check with the buybacks policy to guarantee that they accept the way your device is broken. We recommend that you understand the difference between cracked and broken before selling. Your device can be considered broken if it has any of the following:
Best Places to Sell Broken Apple Watches (Online)
Get 100% of Your Smartwatches Market Value - in cash
Many stores pay with cash for a broken device. Compare quotes, reviews, and other factors to find out where you can get the best deal on a used watch.
BEST Faulty Apple Watch Buyers (Top Payouts)
Average Customer Rating:
4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
TOP PAYOUT
Avg. Cracked Screen:
TOP PAYOUT
*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!
Description
Incorporation: 2018 (UK version started in 2009)
BankMyCell is your go-to place for comparing cell phone trade-in values. From there, you will see who offers the most cash and lock the price for up to 20 days.
We accept devices with broken glass, damaged screens, cracks, or dents that are not fully functional.
Our site compares prices from trade-in sites that buy faulty and used Apple watch models. This includes watches with software and hardware issues.
Payment & Shipping Options
- Mode of Payment: Direct Deposit, Check, Amazon Gift Card, Zelle, PayPal, Cash App
- Receive Payment After: 1-3 days
- Pricelock Duration: 3 to 28 days
- Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Mint, Good, Cracked, Faulty
- What to expect with shipping: Shipping Pack, Shipping Label, Collection Service, Free Returns
Average Customer Rating:
4.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
-21.85% Less
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-53.11% Less
Description
Incorporation: 2007
Decluttr buys smartwatches that are faulty but still power on. These watches might have software issues or hardware issues.
Payment & Shipping Options
- Mode of Payment: PayPal, Deposit, Check
- Receive Payment After: 1 day
- Pricelock Duration: 28 days
- Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Good, Like New, Faulty, Cracked
- What to expect with shipping: Free Shipping Label, Free Returns, Shipping Pack
Average Customer Rating:
4.1 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
-74.07% Less
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-17.10% Less
Description
Year of Establishment: 2009
BuyBackWorld accepts watches with issues like cracked screen, display defects, faulty ports and non functional buttons.
Payment & Shipping Options
- Payment: Check, PayPal, Direct Deposit, Venmo, Gift Cards, PrePaid Debit Card
- Shipping Privileges: Shipping labels, packs, and returns are all free
Average Customer Rating:
4 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
No Offers*
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-88.89% Less
*Smartphone Plus does not accept broken or faulty Apple Watch for trade-in.
Description
Year of Incorporation: 2019
They accept devices with cracks or broken screens, but the device should still turn on. They also accept devices that have minor software and hardware problems.
Payment & Shipping Options
- Payment Options: PayPal, Check
- Payment Timescale: 1 day
- Pricelock Timescale: 14 days
- Conditions Accepted: Like New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
- Shipping Options: Shipping Label, Shipping Pack, Free Returns
*Percentages were calculated using each store’s average price of the five most popular broken Apple Watches.
Who Buys Broken Apple Watches Near Me (In-Store)
Get 14-81% of the device's actual worth online
You may sell your Apple Watch to physical stores if you want an instant payout, but the payment is always much lower than the value you’ll get if you sell online. These locations typically only offer store credit, which means you can upgrade your device with another product using the store currency.
If you are looking for a quick payout and an in-person exchange, you can check retail store websites to see what level of damage they will accept. The following stores all have websites you can get quotes from:
- Apple
- Best Buy
- GameStop
- Walmart
- Target
Sell Apple Watch With Popular Retail Store Chains / ATM Kiosks
Sell Faulty Apple Watch at Popular Retail Store / ATM Kiosks
Average Customer Rating:
4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
TOP PAYOUT
Avg. Cracked Screen:
TOP PAYOUT
*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!
Description
Incorporation: 2018 (UK version started in 2009)
BankMyCell is your go-to place for comparing cell phone trade-in values. From there, you will see who offers the most cash and lock the price for up to 20 days.
We accept devices with broken glass, damaged screens, cracks, or dents that are not fully functional.
Our site compares prices from trade-in sites that buy faulty and used Apple watch models. This includes watches with software and hardware issues.
Payment & Shipping Options
- Mode of Payment: Direct Deposit, Check, Amazon Gift Card, Zelle, PayPal, Cash App
- Receive Payment After: 1-3 days
- Pricelock Duration: 3 to 28 days
- Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Mint, Good, Cracked, Faulty
- What to expect with shipping: Shipping Pack, Shipping Label, Collection Service, Free Returns
Average Customer Rating:
2.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
-14.07% Less
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-48.44% Less
Description
Incorporation: 2001
GameStop accepts any model from the Apple Watch series, even when it’s broken. You can get paid with in-store credit or cash. However, they pay less than $10 for faulty devices. This is much lower compared to other trade-in sites.
Payment & Shipping Options
Mode of Payment: Cash, Store Credit
Receive Payment After: Instant in store
Pricelock Duration: 1 Day
Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Good
What to expect with shipping: Free Shipping
Average Customer Rating:
1.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
-36.67% Less
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-66.67% Less
Description
Incorporation: 1902
Target accepts a broken Apple Watch, but they offer low payouts. After providing details about your watch by answering questions on their website or store, you will immediately receive a quote.
Payment & Shipping Options
Mode of Payment: Target Gift Card
Receive Payment After: 7 days
Pricelock Duration: 7 days
Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Good, Faulty
What to expect with shipping: Shipping Label, Free Returns
Average Customer Rating:
1.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
-81.48% Less
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-88.89% Less
Description
Incorporation: 1962
Walmart buys broken, damaged, or old electronics, but they offer low payouts and only pay via gift cards. When selling with Walmart, remove the accessories, erase all your data, and charge the watch before shipping.
Payment & Shipping Options
Mode of Payment: Walmart Gift Card
Receive Payment After: 14-30 days
Pricelock Duration: 7 days
Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Good, Faulty
What to expect with shipping: Prepaid Shipping Label, Free Returns
Average Customer Rating:
1.3 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
No Offers
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-49.52% Less
*Best Buy does not accept faulty Apple Watch for trade-in.
Description
Like Apple, Best Buy also doesn’t accept a broken Apple Watch for cash. They only offer prices for old electronics and gadgets that are in good condition.
Average Customer Rating:
3.2 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
No Offers*
Avg. Cracked Screen:
No Offers*
*EcoATM does not accept faulty or damaged Apple Watch for trade-in.
Description
Incorporation: 2008
They offer low payouts compared to buyback sites online. Acceptable conditions for an old Apple Watch are those that still power on but have screen issues and minor flaws.
Payment & Shipping Options
Mode of Payment: Cash
Receive Payment After: Instantly (ATM)
Pricelock Duration: N/A
Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Like New, Good, Faulty
What to expect with shipping: None, because you must take your device to their kiosk.
Average Customer Rating:
1.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
No Offers*
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-45.23% Less
*Apple does not accept broken or faulty Apple Watch for trade-in.
Description
Even if they’re the manufacturer of the watch series, Apple Watch doesn’t accept broken old devices for their trade-in program. Save time and effort by crossing out Apple on your buyback options.
**Percentages were calculated using each store’s average price of the five most popular broken Apple Watches.
Sell Apple Watch With Your Carrier In-Store
Carrier In-Store Faulty Apple Watch Quotes
Average Customer Rating:
4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
TOP PAYOUT
Avg. Cracked Screen:
TOP PAYOUT
*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!
Description
Incorporation: 2018 (UK version started in 2009)
BankMyCell is your go-to place for comparing cell phone trade-in values. From there, you will see who offers the most cash and lock the price for up to 20 days.
We accept devices with broken glass, damaged screens, cracks, or dents that are not fully functional.
Our site compares prices from trade-in sites that buy faulty and used Apple watch models. This includes watches with software and hardware issues.
Payment & Shipping Options
- Mode of Payment: Direct Deposit, Check, Amazon Gift Card, Zelle, PayPal, Cash App
- Receive Payment After: 1-3 days
- Pricelock Duration: 3 to 28 days
- Tradeable Conditions: Broken, Mint, Good, Cracked, Faulty
- What to expect with shipping: Shipping Pack, Shipping Label, Collection Service, Free Returns
Average Customer Rating:
1.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
-74.67% Less
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-57.78% Less
Description
Verizon buys tablets in any condition from any network. However, keep in mind that the device’s storage capacity, current condition, and model determine the trade-in value.
In general, a broken device has a lower value. You can upgrade to a new Apple Watch or another device by trading in your old one or using store credit.
Incorporation: 2000
Mode of Payment: Cash, Store Credit
Receive Payment After: 30-60 days
Pricelock Duration: 30 days
What to expect with shipping: Broken, Good, Faulty
Payment & Shipping Options
- Payment Timeline: 60 days
- Payment Methods: Bill credits (deducted monthly after a new purchase)
- Shipping: Free shipping label / instore
Average Customer Rating:
1.2 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
-80.00% Less
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-66.67% Less
Description
The model and current condition of an Apple Watch determine its value. Broken watches can be traded in, and the price will be adjusted accordingly.
You must remove all data from the watch before selling it.
Incorporation: 1983
Mode of Payment: Store Credit
Receive Payment After: 60-90 days
Pricelock Duration: 30 days
What to expect with shipping: Broken, Good, Faulty, Locked
Payment & Shipping Options
- Payment Timeline: 60 days
- Payment Methods: Bill credits (deducted monthly after a new purchase)
- Shipping: Free shipping label / instore
Average Customer Rating:
1.2 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
No Offers*
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-71.11% Less
*Sprint does not accept broken or faulty Apple Watch for trade-in.
Description
Sprint only accepts devices in good condition, not broken smartwatches. Their buyback program only accepts store credit as payment. You can use the credit to upgrade to a new device.
Average Customer Rating:
1.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot
Avg. Broken/Faulty:
No Offers*
Avg. Cracked Screen:
-71.11% Less
*T-Mobile does not accept broken or faulty Apple Watch for trade-in.
Description
They do not accept smartwatches that are broken. If you have a non-faulty device and are a T-Mobile customer, you can trade-in your watch in good condition.
The company determines the trade-in value based on the current condition and model of your Apple Watch. You can trade in at either their physical location or online.
*Percentages were calculated using each store’s average price of the five most popular broken Apple Watches.
Can You Trade in a Broken Apple Watch?
Many companies accept trade-ins for a faulty and used Apple Watch, whatever its condition is. Just make sure that your watch is not broken in half or crushed.
A used Apple Watch is usually traded-in with physical stores like Apple or carriers. However, payments are typically low, and broken smartwatches are often excluded from their offers.
There are better chances of selling a faulty Apple Watch via online buyback sites and being offered higher cash payments.
Here are some of the characteristics of a broken Apple Watch:
- Screen cracks or damage
- Touchscreen isn’t working
- Faulty battery
- Water or liquid damage
- Faulty speaker and microphone
- Speakers aren’t working
- Unresponsive button and keys
- Port failure
- Problems with software or the operating system
- The watch doesn’t power on
Where to Sell Broken Apple Watches For Cash?
If you have a faulty and used Apple Watch, you can trade it in or have it repaired. Having it fixed means you can use your device again, but it will cost a lot of money. Trading in allows you to get paid in cash and upgrade or buy a new gadget.
Online buyback companies offer Apple Watch trade-ins and will buy your watch with cash. We compiled the top places where you can sell your old Apple Watch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sell my Apple Watch even if it's damaged?
You can still sell your damaged Apple Watch, whether it has water damage, cosmetic issues, or other problems. Be sure to accurately describe its condition, especially if it has significant scratching, wear, or liquid damage. Many buyers specialize in refurbishing or salvaging parts from damaged devices.
Is there any value in a cracked Apple Watch?
While a cracked Apple Watch may have some value, it’s typically minimal, especially if the crack affects its functionality. In many cases, the cost of repairing the device may exceed any potential trade-in or resale value. Selling it for parts might be a more practical option to recover some value.
What should I do with a broken Apple Watch?
If your Apple Watch is broken, consider Apple’s service options, which may involve a repair fee. Although accidental damage isn’t covered by warranty, AppleCare+ plans might provide support for damage, giving you options for repair or replacement.
