Best Places to Sell Your Old Apple Watch

17 Best Places to Sell Your Apple Watch (Cash & credit) (Feb 2024)

You are here:
By Ash Turner
As CEO of CompareMyMobile.com and BankMyCell.com since 2009, Ash has been a pivotal figure in the mobile tech industry. With a background in managing Brightstar’s PhoneRecycleBank, he boasts extensive experience with global carriers and MVNOs like T-Mobile and O2, and leading manufacturers such as Apple and Samsung.

Learn about our editorial process

| Updated on February 16, 2024
Fact Checked By
Joey Bobiles
Joey is adept at creating comprehensive comparison guides and product reviews for devices from brands like Apple, Samsung, and Google. His expertise extends to thorough evaluations of smartphones, tablets, smartwatches, MVNOs, and phone plans, all while simplifying intricate technical information into easily understandable content.

Learn about our editorial process

Edited By
Kim Juanillo
Kim, an editor with a rich background in digital content management and developmental psychology, brings a unique blend of analytical and creative skills to BankMyCell. With her background in Psychology, Kim is adept at understanding complex concepts and transforming them into engaging, accessible content.

Learn about our editorial process

  • Online buyback stores provide the highest trade-in price for an Apple Watch. Before selling your device, compare prices and see reviews first to get the best deal.
  • Private marketplaces will pay you 10%-20% more than other buyback sites, but creating your listing and engaging with customers will take your time.
  • In-store and carriers offer the lowest prices and will only pay via store credit, but they occasionally offer upgrades.

Sell your Apple Watch on BankMyCell for the Highest Cash Payout

BankMyCell compares over 100,000+ quotes and customer reviews from 20+ trusted buyback stores every 15 minutes via our data feeds, making us America’s #1 time-saving trade-in supermarket.

*Percentages were calculated through the average price of five different Apple Watch models from each store.

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers
Buyback CompanyPrice Difference vs. Best PriceTrustpilot RatingPayout Type
BankMyCell
Compare 20+ quotes
BEST OFFER4.4 out of 5Cash
GadgetPickup -9.41%4.8 out of 5Cash
SmartphonesPLUS -24.71%4.7 out of 5Cash
Cell Tech Express -29.41%4.8 out of 5Cash
BuyBackWorld -29.41%4.1 out of 5Cash
In-Store Trade-inPrice DifferenceTrustpilot RatingPayout Type
BankMyCell
Compare 20+ quotes
BEST OFFER4.4 out of 5Cash
GameStop -11.76% 2.4 out of 5Store Credit
Best Buy -17.65%1.3 out of 5Store Credit
Walmart -29.41% 1.4 out of 5Store Credit
Target -64.71% 1.9 out of 5Store Credit
Carrier Trade-inPrice DifferenceTrustpilot RatingPayout Type
BankMyCell
Compare 20+ quotes
BEST OFFER4.4 out of 5Cash
Verizon-55.29%1.4 out of 5Store Credit
AT&T-64.71% 1.2 out of 5Store Credit
Sprint -70.59%1.1 out of 5Store Credit
T-Mobile -70.59% 1.4 out of 5Store Credit

BEST Payouts (41%-123% More)

It's Simple - Register your sale, drop your phone off at a local postal service and earn more

Compare Apple Watch Buyback/Trade-in Deals

Best Online Buyback Stores (Cash)

BEST Online Apple Watch Buyback Store (Cash)

bankmycell logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

TOP PAYOUT

*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers

Description

BankMyCell is the best site to sell Apple Watches. It allows you to choose the model, size, condition, and style of the Apple Watch model.

Following that, you will be given a list of the top prices offered by buyback companies.

This overview will assist you in determining the best store to sell your Apple Watch. As a result, you get more money for your device.

The website provides quotes from each buyback store and allows you to specify the condition, size, and style of your Apple Watch for more accurate pricing.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: Mint condition, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Direct Deposit, PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle, Amazon Gift Card
Things to Expect: Free Shipping Label, Shipping Pack, Free Returns in case it doesn’t get accepted after the final inspection, Collection Service

Gadget Pickup Logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-9.41% Less

Description

GadgetPickup has a wide range of payment options, such as PayPal and paper checks. However, you might not get paid in cash.

They provide a higher trade-in value compared to other trade-in programs and online marketplaces.

The site offers instant quotes for your Apple Watch, but you must first describe its current condition, size, and style. Once the item is inspected, the site pays within two days.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
  • Payment Options: PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle
  • Things to Expect: Shipping Label, Free Returns
smartphone plus logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.7 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-24.71% Less

Description

SmartphonesPLUS offers a high trade-in value for used Apple Watches compared to other trade-in programs.

They provide free shipping and returns if ever they do not push through with the sale. This usually happens when they discover that your device’s actual condition is different from what you originally stated.

The site offers instant quotes for your Apple Watch, but you must first describe its current condition, size, and style.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
  • Payment Options: PayPal
  • Things to Expect: Shipping Label, Shipping Pack, Free Returns
Cell Tech logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 5

4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-29.41% Less

Description

Celltech’s high Trustpilot rating suggests that it is one of the best buyback stores available. They provide a high trade-in value for an Apple Watch. They also offer two payment options.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
  • Payment Options: PayPal, Check
  • Shipping: Free Shipping Label
Buyback World logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4

4.1 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-29.41% Less

Description

Buyback World has a wide range of payment options, such as PayPal and paper checks.

The site offers instant quotes for your Apple Watch, but you must first describe its current condition, size, and style. Once the item is inspected, the site pays within seven days.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Payment: Check, PayPal, Direct Deposit, Venmo, Gift Cards, PrePaid Debit Card
  • Shipping Privileges: Shipping labels, packs, and returns are all free

*Price check quotes based on a 1 year old Apple Watch (Feb 2024)

Best Apple Watch Seller Marketplaces (Cash)

Best Apple Watch Seller Marketplaces

bankmycell logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

TOP PAYOUT

*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers

Description

BankMyCell is the best site to sell Apple Watches. It allows you to choose the model, size, condition, and style of the Apple Watch model.

Following that, you will be given a list of the top prices offered by buyback companies.

This overview will assist you in determining the best store to sell your Apple Watch. As a result, you get more money for your device.

The website provides quotes from each buyback store and allows you to specify the condition, size, and style of your Apple Watch for more accurate pricing.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: Mint condition, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Direct Deposit, PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle, Amazon Gift Card
Things to Expect: Free Shipping Label, Shipping Pack, Free Returns in case it doesn’t get accepted after the final inspection, Collection Service

ebay logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1

1.2 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

Auction*

*eBay is an auction website, prices listed vary.

Description

When you trade in an Apple Watch, you must post a listing on their website. It entails describing the item for sale and uploading photos of your item. You should also write an accurate description for the listing and set your own price, which can take time.

You are able to sell your Apple Watch for the best price possible. eBay, however, takes a fee of up to 15% of the sale price.

eBay is a marketplace that facilitates consumer-to-consumer transactions. The site offers instant quotes for your Apple Watch, but you must first describe its current condition, size, and style.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: PayPal
Things to Expect: No Free Shipping

*Price check quotes based on a 1 year old Apple Watch (Feb 2024)

Best In-Store Apple Watch Trade-in (Store Credit Only)

Apple Watch Retail Store Trade In Options

bankmycell logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

TOP PAYOUT

*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers

Description

BankMyCell is the best site to sell Apple Watches. It allows you to choose the model, size, condition, and style of the Apple Watch model.

Following that, you will be given a list of the top prices offered by buyback companies.

This overview will assist you in determining the best store to sell your Apple Watch. As a result, you get more money for your device.

The website provides quotes from each buyback store and allows you to specify the condition, size, and style of your Apple Watch for more accurate pricing.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: Mint condition, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Direct Deposit, PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle, Amazon Gift Card
Things to Expect: Free Shipping Label, Shipping Pack, Free Returns in case it doesn’t get accepted after the final inspection, Collection Service

GameStop logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 2.5

2.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-11.76% Less

*GameStop does not accept Apple Watches which are broken or faulty

Description

GameStop allows you to be paid in cash if you prefer. However, they offer less value for the money option compared to store credit. You might want to choose store credit or look for other buyback options.

GameStop accepts Apple Watch trade-ins, whether the device is already damaged or still in excellent working order.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Cash, Gamestop Gift Card
Things to Expect: No free shipping

bestbuy logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1

1.3 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-17.65% Less

*Best Buy only accept fully functioning Apple Watches with no damage.

Description

If you’re a frequent customer at Best Buy, trading at their store is a good option because they pay via store credit or gift cards. These payment options are good for upgrading or buying other electronics from the store.

Sell your Apple Watch for a Best Buy Gift Card.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Best Buy Gift Card
Things to Expect: Shipping Pack

walmart logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1

1.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-29.41% Less

Description

Walmart offers a reasonable trade-in value for various used Apple Watches. They also only pay via Walmart Gift Cards, which are used to purchase items from their store.

The site offers instant quotes for your Apple Watch, but you must first describe its current condition, size, and style.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Walmart Gift Card
Things to Expect: Shipping Label, Free Returns

target logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 2

1.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-64.71% Less

Description

Target only pays with gift cards, so it should be the last option on your list unless you intend to buy something from their store.

The Target Tech program allows you to trade your Apple Watch for a Target Gift Card.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: New, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Target Gift Card
Things to Expect: Shipping Label, Free Returns

*Price check quotes based on a 1 year old Apple Watch (Feb 2024)

Best Carrier Apple Watch Trade-in Deal

Carrier quotes are as low as retail store prices. It’s also worth noting that they pay with store credit rather than cash.

Consider trading in an Apple Watch with them only if you intend to upgrade your device. It is due to carriers providing special deals and incentives for your item’s contract.

Carrier In-Store Faulty Apple Watch Quotes

bankmycell logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

TOP PAYOUT

*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers

Description

BankMyCell is the best site to sell Apple Watches. It allows you to choose the model, size, condition, and style of the Apple Watch model.

Following that, you will be given a list of the top prices offered by buyback companies.

This overview will assist you in determining the best store to sell your Apple Watch. As a result, you get more money for your device.

The website provides quotes from each buyback store and allows you to specify the condition, size, and style of your Apple Watch for more accurate pricing.

Payment & Shipping Options

Conditions Accepted: Mint condition, Good, Cracked, Faulty
Payment Options: Direct Deposit, PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle, Amazon Gift Card
Things to Expect: Free Shipping Label, Shipping Pack, Free Returns in case it doesn’t get accepted after the final inspection, Collection Service

verizon logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1.5

1.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-55.29% Less

Description

They accept trade-ins for old Apple Watch units.

at&t logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1

1.2 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-64.71% Less

Description

They accept trade-ins for old Apple Watch units.

Sprint logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1

1.1 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-70.59% Less

Description

They accept trade-ins for old Apple Watch units.

T-mobile logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1.5

1.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-70.59% Less

Description

They accept trade-ins for old Apple Watch units.

*Price check quotes based on a 1 year old Apple Watch (Feb 2024)

Where Can I Sell My Apple Watch?

You could miss out on hundreds of dollars if you’re unaware of the actual value of your Apple Watch. For this reason, it’s important to weigh all of your options.

Some platforms gain you more cash, but you must post the ad yourself, which takes up your time. On the other hand, some stores have convenient trade-in programs but only offer gift cards as payment rather than cash.

We listed the top platforms of Apple Watch buyers into three categories and included the list of top stores under each platform. We also included reviews and sample quotes, so you know what to expect from them.

Buyback stores (online): It's an easy way to trade in your Apple Watch (High Payouts)
Private marketplaces: Its system is based on person-to-person interaction and requires you to post your classified ad (High Payouts).
In-store and carriers: They offer upgrades and promotional deals but only pay with store credit (Low-Medium Payouts).

How to Get Paid the Most Money for Used Apple Watches

Keep Your Device in Good Condition

You’ll get the best value for your Apple Watch if it’s still in good condition. It includes having no screen damage or hardware issues.

For this reason, it’s best to take good care of your device. Use cases to protect it from possible water damage or scratches. You can also use a screen protector for an added layer of protection.

Compare Resale Prices

Before trading in an Apple Watch, please do your homework by comparing quotations from different stores and reading reviews to get a sense of what to expect from them.

It is where a comparison service like BankMyCell comes in handy. It weighs your options depending on what’s convenient for you. It allows you to select from stores that offer your preferred payment option. Prefer to be paid in cash or via direct deposit? BankMyCell has it covered.

Best for Broken Apple Watches

You should expect the value of your current Apple Watch to drop as newer models are released on the market, much more if your Apple Watch is broken. This is why it is necessary to sell your broken device as early as possible.

Over time, it will lose value if you leave it merely gathering dust, and you may have difficulty selling it. To maximize your earnings, sell it as quickly as possible.

Summary

Here are the things you can look at to help guide you before selling an old Apple Watch.

Comparing quotes is essential.

For one, comparing trade-in values is essential. Many stores and carriers are willing to repurchase gadgets and items like Apple Watches.

However, the price is dependent on its current condition and other factors. Instead of selling it to the first shop you come across, considering your options will help you get the best price.

Person-to-person marketplaces are a great option.

When it comes to marketplaces, eBay and Swappa are your best bets since they allow you to set your own prices, and you get to sell your item directly to the buyer.

These platforms usually require that your Apple Watch is still in good condition.

These websites also have service fees, ranging from $5-$35 depending on your device’s model and selling price.

Use BankMyCell to compare Apple Watch prices.

Do you own a faulty Apple Watch? Some consumers are still willing to buy your item. They may deconstruct it for spare parts or have it repaired for use again.

Don’t leave your Apple Watch at home to gather dust. Compare prices for broken or damaged Apple Watches with BankMyCell and trade them in.