Best Places to Sell Your Old Xbox

10 Best Places to Sell Your Xbox For Cash (Feb 2024)

You are here:
By Ash Turner
As CEO of CompareMyMobile.com and BankMyCell.com since 2009, Ash has been a pivotal figure in the mobile tech industry. With a background in managing Brightstar’s PhoneRecycleBank, he boasts extensive experience with global carriers and MVNOs like T-Mobile and O2, and leading manufacturers such as Apple and Samsung.

Learn about our editorial process

| Updated on February 16, 2024
Fact Checked By
Marlene Centeno
Marlene specializes in creating comprehensive guides for smartphones, tablets, and smartwatches from leading brands like Apple, Samsung, and Google, demonstrating a deep understanding of these technologies.

Learn about our editorial process

Edited By
Kim Juanillo
Kim, an editor with a rich background in digital content management and developmental psychology, brings a unique blend of analytical and creative skills to BankMyCell. With her background in Psychology, Kim is adept at understanding complex concepts and transforming them into engaging, accessible content.

Learn about our editorial process

  • Online buyback stores provide the highest value for a used Xbox unit among all your options. Compare prices and read reviews before selling your item to get the best deal!
  • You can trade in your used game consoles on marketplaces, however, this can take some time because you will need to create an ad and reply to customers. 
  • Carriers and in-store shops offer the lowest trade-in price for a used Xbox console, but they occasionally offer upgrade deals. 

Sell at Your Convenience with the Best Price for Your Xbox

BankMyCell compares over 100,000+ quotes and customer reviews from 20+ trusted buyback stores every 15 minutes via our data feeds, making us America’s #1 time-saving trade-in supermarket.

*Percentages were calculated through the average price of five different Samsung Galaxy phones from each store.

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers
Buyback CompanyPrice Difference vs. Best PriceTrustpilot RatingPayout Type
BankMyCell
Compare 20+ quotes
BEST OFFER4.4 out of 5Cash
Cell Tech-3.85%4.8 out of 5Cash
Gadget Pickup -4.62%5 out of 5Cash
Marketplace Trade-inPrice DifferenceTrustpilot RatingPayout Type
BankMyCell
Compare 20+ quotes
BEST OFFER4.4 out of 5Cash
eBayAuction*1.2 out of 5Cash
RedditMarketplace*4.9 out of 5Cash
In-Store Trade-inPrice DifferenceTrustpilot RatingPayout Type
BankMyCell
Compare 20+ quotes
BEST OFFER4.4 out of 5Cash
GameStop-3.85%2.4 out of 5Store Credit
Best Buy-63.46% 1.3 out of 5Store Credit

BEST Payouts (41%-123% More)

It's Simple - Register your sale, drop your phone off at a local postal service and earn more

Compare Xbox Buyback/Trade-in Deals

Best Online Buyback Stores (Cash)

Xbox Buyback Store Options

bankmycell logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

TOP PAYOUT

*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers

Description

BankMyCell offers instant quotes for used Xbox Series S and Xbox Series X consoles.

It is the best place to trade in your Xbox because it provides flexibility on payment methods and free shipping. They also accept a wide range of conditions for devices. These things can help you decide where to sell your old Xbox.

The website lets you compare quotes for Xbox sellers with options based on the condition of the game console. It also allows you to select from your preferred modes of payment and shipping processes.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment: Direct Deposit, PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle, Amazon Gift Card
  • Things to Expect: Prepaid shipping label and free shipping pack, free returns after a failed final inspection, collection service
Cell Tech logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 5

4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-3.85% Less

Description

Cell Tech is an Xbox buyback site that provides a reasonable value for a used Xbox console.

Their website includes a track order button that allows you to track the shipment of your item. However, it only accepts two payment methods: PayPal and direct check.

The website offers quotes for Xbox sellers, with options based on the condition of the gaming consoles, modes of payment, and shipping processes.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment:Check, PayPal
  • Things to Expect: Prepaid shipping label
gadgetpickup logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 5

5 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-4.62% Less

Description

GadgetPickup is a buyback shop that provides a high trade-in value for your old Xbox. It also accepts various payment methods, including PayPal and Cash App.

Your item will be shipped for free, but if it is discovered to have damage that is not covered by the condition you stated, it will be returned. There are no fees for returns.

The site offers quotes for Xbox sellers, with options based on the condition of the Xbox consoles, payment options, and shipping processes.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment: Check, PayPal, Cash App, Zelle
  • Things to Expect: Free shipping, free returns

*Price check quotes based on the latest Xbox (Feb 2024)

Best Xbox Seller Marketplaces (Cash)

Xbox Seller Marketplace Options

bankmycell logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

TOP PAYOUT

*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers

Description

BankMyCell offers instant quotes for used Xbox Series S and Xbox Series X consoles.

It is the best place to trade in your Xbox because it provides flexibility on payment methods and free shipping. They also accept a wide range of conditions for devices. These things can help you decide where to sell your old Xbox.

The website lets you compare quotes for Xbox sellers with options based on the condition of the game console. It also allows you to select from your preferred modes of payment and shipping processes.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment: Direct Deposit, PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle, Amazon Gift Card
  • Things to Expect: Prepaid shipping label and free shipping pack, free returns after a failed final inspection, collection service
ebay logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1

1.2 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

Auction*

*eBay is an auction site, prices vary

Description

eBay provides you a platform to sell your device at a high trade-in value since your price the item yourself. However, you will be dealing with your customer directly.

It means you are also in charge of your listing, from taking photos of your item to posting the ad and responding to interested buyers’ questions. A sale, however, is subject to eBay’s additional fees.

The website offers you a platform to create a listing for your used device. eBay collects a fee for every successful sale.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment: PayPal
  • Things to Expect: No free shipping or shipping pack. You will have to ship the item to the customer yourself.
Reddit logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 5

4.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

Marketplace*

Description

r/GameSale Reddit Thread

r/GameSale is a community or forum hosted on a social networking site called Reddit. It is a straightforward platform for finding used Xbox buyers online. You’re instantly reaching your target market because the thread’s members are all interested in buying or selling Xbox games and consoles.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment: Depends on your agreement with the buyer.
  • Things to Expect: NO free shipping or shipping pack

*Price check quotes based on the latest Xbox (Feb 2024)

Best In-Store Xbox Trade-in (Store Credit Only)

In-Store Xbox Trade-in Options

bankmycell logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 4.5

4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

TOP PAYOUT

*Compare everyone’s deals here, Guaranteed Top Payouts!

Compare popular online, carrier & in-store trade-in offers

Description

BankMyCell offers instant quotes for used Xbox Series S and Xbox Series X consoles.

It is the best place to trade in your Xbox because it provides flexibility on payment methods and free shipping. They also accept a wide range of conditions for devices. These things can help you decide where to sell your old Xbox.

The website lets you compare quotes for Xbox sellers with options based on the condition of the game console. It also allows you to select from your preferred modes of payment and shipping processes.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment: Direct Deposit, PayPal, Check, Cash App, Zelle, Amazon Gift Card
  • Things to Expect: Prepaid shipping label and free shipping pack, free returns after a failed final inspection, collection service
GameStop logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 2.5

2.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-3.85% Less

Description

GameStop’s Trustpilot rating indicates that it is one of the best places to sell Xbox units. However, they only offer two payment options and do not provide free shipping.

The website offers an instant price for Xbox sellers, with options based on the condition of the video game consoles, payment options, and shipping processes.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Mint
  • Mode of Payment: Cash, Gamestop Gift Card
  • Things to Expect: NO free shipping or shipping pack
bestbuy logo

Average Customer Rating:

icon review 1

1.3 out of 5 on Trustpilot

Avg. Trade-in Quote:

-63.46% Less

Description

Other retailers provide a better deal on a used Xbox. However, if you frequently shop at Best Buy, this is an excellent option because they pay with a gift card or store credit.

You can use the gift card to upgrade your device or make another purchase from their shop.

The website offers an instant price for Xbox sellers, with options based on the condition of the gaming consoles, payment options, and shipping processes.

Payment & Shipping Options

  • Tradeable Conditions: Good, Poor, Not working
  • Mode of Payment: Best Buy Gift Card
  • Things to Expect: Free shipping pack

*Price check quotes based on the latest Xbox (Feb 2024)

Best Classified Ad Websites

Classified ad websites allow you to create a listing like marketplaces. This means you can also get a higher payout since you set your own price, and you can select the mode of payment.

However, there is a risk of meeting scammers and the payment transaction is not too secure. As a seller, you usually have to meet with buyers and the payments are made in person.

OfferUp

OfferUp is an excellent place to sell a used Xbox console since it allows you to create a listing locally. You post a classified ad as the seller and buyers near you are able to see it.

This site has buyer ratings, and if your profile lacks one, people may be hesitant to buy from you.

The site allows you to set up your own price and create your own listing for buyers near you.

Craigslist

This is another site where you can sell your used Xbox locally. The platform will require you to post your ad for your used item. You will also need to photograph your item and respond to questions from potential buyers.

You set a price for your device based on the similar Xbox models and condition.

Where Can I Sell My Xbox For Cash?

Many stores accept used Xbox console trade-ins. It’s simply a matter of comparing prices to determine where you can get the best deal on your item. Weigh your options by considering each store’s quotes, modes of payment, and processes before selling your console online.

Platforms where to sell your used Xbox

You could lose hundreds of dollars if you fail to compare quotes carefully for your video game or console online trade-in. To assist you in deciding where to sell your Xbox, we have categorized your options as follows:

Buyback Stores: High payout and free shipping. They require you to register sales online
Local Classified Ads: They provide a high payout. However, you have to put up the listing yourself, including taking photos, haggling offers, and shipping the item directly to the buyer. This might not be your best option if you prefer a process that takes less effort on your part
In-Store Trade-ins: They provide low to medium payouts, but their processes are more straightforward than other stores. They pay with in-store credit or gift cards instead of cash, which might be helpful for customers who want to upgrade or avail of store promotions. This option might not be for you, however, if you want to be paid instantly in cash.

How to Get Paid The Most Money for Used Xboxes

Compare Resale Prices

To find the best site for selling your Xbox, it is crucial to compare quotes to ensure you receive the best price for your used console.

You can do so at BankMyCell.com, which provides an overview of the stores that accept trade-ins for your console online.

Our filters also include the item’s condition that stores accept, their payment methods, etc. To get instant trade-in quotes, click the website’s More Electronics menu, select Sell Game Consoles, and choose Xbox.

Keep Your Device In Good Condition

You can sell your console for a high price if it is in excellent condition. How can you say it’s in good shape? Your item should not have any cosmetic damage or software problems. It is also favorable if you still have the original packaging.

Do you intend to sell your Xbox games soon? Then, make sure that you clean it regularly and store it in a secure location.

Best for Broken Xboxes

Don’t worry if you have a broken Xbox; there are still stores that will accept it as a trade-in device. Don’t leave your device at home collecting dust because it will only depreciate. Instead, sell it the soonest you can to get the highest possible price.

Summary: Get the Best Price for Your Used Xbox

Remember to compare trade-in prices.

Comparing the current offers for an Xbox console, available payment methods, and shipping options are essential when considering where to sell your device.

BankMyCell makes it easier for you to make the best choice because it instantly filters out the highest store offers for your device. It helps you select the best place to sell your games/consoles.

Marketplaces are also a good option.

For seller-to-buyer marketplaces, Swappa might be the better option compared to eBay for trading in a used console. They are able to provide you with the best Xbox trade-in value.

However, it’s good to keep in mind that they charge a 3-5% fee to both the seller and buyer for each sale.

BankMyCell also compares prices for broken Xboxes

The best place to visit when thinking about selling used Xbox consoles in various conditions is BankMyCell’s website. They have a wide database of shops and retailers that provide offers for even broken units.

Visit BankMyCell.com now!